Articles‎ > ‎

The FM is expected to be a cross between Ma Durga and Santa Claus

Keeping the goalposts in place when the football game is on is the best signal of

this Budget

Roopen Roy (Views are personal)

In most countries, the Budget is a process of raising resources through taxation 

and an authorization for spending them for designated activities of the nation. 

In our country the budget is far more than that. It is a pulpit for making policy 

announcements, launching new projects, informing the citizens about the state of 

the nation and its economy and setting the directions for the journey specially if 

a new government has come to power. The FM in India is expected to be a cross 

between Goddess Durga , who slays the demon and eradicates all evils and Santa 

Claus known for his boundless munificence and bounty. No FM can measure up to 

such high expectations.

The courage of the FM comes through not his long speech or his promises. The 

courage quietly comes through in what he has done or , more significantly, chosen 

not to do. He has not listened to the advice of certain Indian economists ensconced 

in cooler climes who have goaded him to provide huge fiscal concessions and 

embark on a bold infrastructure spending spree, fiscal prudence be damned and 

let inflation devour the hindmost. He has stuck to the fiscal deficit target of 4.1% 

of GDP set by his predecessor. It is an act of fiscal prudence that also has a deft 

political twist to it.

He has taken a significant step to lift business sentiments and bring back the trust 

and confidence of foreign investors. Global companies have not been complaining 

about the rate of taxation in India. Large reputed Fortune 500 companies were 

worried that they were not able to predict with certainty their tax obligations 

because of retrospective amendments to the Income tax Act, confusion about 

transfer pricing norms and an aggressive tax administration out to collect more 

by every means. Imagine how Messi and Klose will feel on Sunday if the referee 

changes the goalposts when they are kicking the ball in and reserves the right to 

disallow goals with retrospective effect!!

The FM is also putting in place dispute resolution mechanisms so that investors 

can focus on the market and not fritter their time in the chambers of lawyers or 

courts battling tax collectors! He has promised a “stable and predictable taxation 


 He has vowed to clean three things in his maiden budget : the Ganga (Rs 2037 

crores) , the banking system (by infusing Rs 240,000 crores ) and black money 

(he has promised “bold steps”) . If that is not bold in its aspiration –what is? 

By allowing up to 49% in defense manufacturing, he has encouraged the flow 

of investments and technology in defense production. Today we buy outright 

from foreign suppliers of defense and military equipment .So long as we spend 

on defense equipment (and we are one of the largest buyers), it is better to 

manufacture them in India creating jobs, absorbing new technology and paving 

way for R&D spends and innovation. 

Likewise Insurance is highly capital-intensive and needs global networks to 

compete. Lifting of the FDI limit to 49% will enhance the interest of global 

players. Although hidden in the forest of his long speech, his announcement of 

e-commerce platforms will be keenly watched by foreign investors and already 

consultants are beginning to pour over the fine print because whether it is the devil 

or the angel it is always in the details. The FM has said that FDI in manufacturing 

is on the automatic route. His exact words , “ The manufacturing units will be 

allowed to sell its products through retail including e-commerce platforms without 

any additional approval.” Even today e-retail and e-commerce are rapidly growing 

across the world. Amazon, for instance, is one of the largest retailers on this planet. 

If FDI is allowed to come in to set up e-commerce platforms, a quiet revolution in 

retail has just been ignited.

Given the constraints of time and the need to do some tight-rope walking on fiscal 

deficits and tax provisions, I would have a lot of sympathies for him.